A polytropic process for an ideal gas is represented by the equation $P{V^n}$ constant. If gamma is the ratio of specific heat ${{\rm{C}}_P}/{{\rm{C}}_V}$. Then the value of n for which molar heat capacity of the process is negative is given as
A. $\gamma \; > \,n$
B. $\gamma \; > \,n\, > 1$
C. $\,n\, > \,\gamma $
D. none as it is not possible
Answer
654.3k+ views
Hint:The expression for the molar specific heat in a polytropic process is given by
${\rm{C}}\;{\rm{ = }}\;\dfrac{{\rm{R}}}{{\gamma \; - 1}}\; = \dfrac{{\rm{R}}}{{n - 1}}$
We are given a negative question. Hence, we are to find only those values of n for which the entire expression becomes negative.
Complete step by step answer:
A polytropic process is mathematically expressed as ${\rm{P}}{{\rm{V}}^n}\; = \;$constant.
Where P is the pressure, V is the volume and n is the polytropic index.
Value of (n) ranges from 0 to infinity but in the situation given above; we have to find only those values of n for which molar specific heat, i.e., is C negative.
Molar specific heat is given as
${\rm{C}}\;{\rm{ = }}\;\dfrac{{\rm{R}}}{{\gamma \; - 1}}\; - \dfrac{{\rm{R}}}{{n - 1}}$
Here R is the universal gas constant and $\gamma $ is the ratio of specific heat of gases.
Upon simplifying the above relation we get,
${\rm{C = }}\dfrac{{(n - 1){\rm{R - }}\,{\rm{(}}\gamma {\rm{ - 1)R}}}}{{{\rm{(}}\gamma {\rm{ - 1)}}(n - 1){\rm{ }}}}\; = \dfrac{{{\rm{nR - R - }}\gamma {\rm{R}}\;{\rm{ + }}\,{\rm{R}}}}{{{\rm{(}}\gamma {\rm{ - 1)}}(n - 1)}}$
$ \Rightarrow \;\dfrac{{({\rm{n - }}\gamma {\rm{) R}}}}{{(\gamma - 1)\;(n - 1)}}$
Now we will focus on three terms of the expression obtained and analyses their range,
$(n - \gamma ),(n - 1),(\gamma - 1)$
We have two relations,
$\gamma \; = \dfrac{{{{\rm{C}}_{\rm{P}}}}}{{{{\rm{C}}_{\rm{V}}}}}\;$ And ${{\rm{C}}_P}\; - {{\rm{C}}_{\rm{V}}}\; = \,R$
These expressions suggest that,
${{\rm{C}}_P}{\rm{ > }}{{\rm{C}}_V}\;$and hence $\gamma \; > 1$
So, $\gamma \; - 1$ it will always be positive.
We can conclude that for C to be negative,$(n - \gamma )$ will be negative. That is
$n - \gamma < 0$
$ \Rightarrow n\; < \gamma $ ………… (1)
And (n-1) will be positive i.e.
$n\; - 1 > \;0$
$n\; > \;1$ …….. (2)
From I and 2 equations we conclude that,
$\gamma \; > \,n\, > 1$
Therefore (B) option is correct.
Note: For any question of the type where we are supposed to predict the values of a variable, it is a good practice to factorize the expression and then one by one evaluate each factor to get the values. Good care must be taken by solving the inequalities.
${\rm{C}}\;{\rm{ = }}\;\dfrac{{\rm{R}}}{{\gamma \; - 1}}\; = \dfrac{{\rm{R}}}{{n - 1}}$
We are given a negative question. Hence, we are to find only those values of n for which the entire expression becomes negative.
Complete step by step answer:
A polytropic process is mathematically expressed as ${\rm{P}}{{\rm{V}}^n}\; = \;$constant.
Where P is the pressure, V is the volume and n is the polytropic index.
Value of (n) ranges from 0 to infinity but in the situation given above; we have to find only those values of n for which molar specific heat, i.e., is C negative.
Molar specific heat is given as
${\rm{C}}\;{\rm{ = }}\;\dfrac{{\rm{R}}}{{\gamma \; - 1}}\; - \dfrac{{\rm{R}}}{{n - 1}}$
Here R is the universal gas constant and $\gamma $ is the ratio of specific heat of gases.
Upon simplifying the above relation we get,
${\rm{C = }}\dfrac{{(n - 1){\rm{R - }}\,{\rm{(}}\gamma {\rm{ - 1)R}}}}{{{\rm{(}}\gamma {\rm{ - 1)}}(n - 1){\rm{ }}}}\; = \dfrac{{{\rm{nR - R - }}\gamma {\rm{R}}\;{\rm{ + }}\,{\rm{R}}}}{{{\rm{(}}\gamma {\rm{ - 1)}}(n - 1)}}$
$ \Rightarrow \;\dfrac{{({\rm{n - }}\gamma {\rm{) R}}}}{{(\gamma - 1)\;(n - 1)}}$
Now we will focus on three terms of the expression obtained and analyses their range,
$(n - \gamma ),(n - 1),(\gamma - 1)$
We have two relations,
$\gamma \; = \dfrac{{{{\rm{C}}_{\rm{P}}}}}{{{{\rm{C}}_{\rm{V}}}}}\;$ And ${{\rm{C}}_P}\; - {{\rm{C}}_{\rm{V}}}\; = \,R$
These expressions suggest that,
${{\rm{C}}_P}{\rm{ > }}{{\rm{C}}_V}\;$and hence $\gamma \; > 1$
So, $\gamma \; - 1$ it will always be positive.
We can conclude that for C to be negative,$(n - \gamma )$ will be negative. That is
$n - \gamma < 0$
$ \Rightarrow n\; < \gamma $ ………… (1)
And (n-1) will be positive i.e.
$n\; - 1 > \;0$
$n\; > \;1$ …….. (2)
From I and 2 equations we conclude that,
$\gamma \; > \,n\, > 1$
Therefore (B) option is correct.
Note: For any question of the type where we are supposed to predict the values of a variable, it is a good practice to factorize the expression and then one by one evaluate each factor to get the values. Good care must be taken by solving the inequalities.
Recently Updated Pages
Write structures of the following compounds i 2 Chloro3methylpentane class 11 chemistry CBSE

What is BLO What is the full form of BLO class 8 social science CBSE

Explain the Treaty of Vienna of 1815 class 10 social science CBSE

A Paragraph on Pollution in about 100-150 Words

XIX+XXX A 49 B 51 C 55 D 44 class 5 maths CBSE

If x a + bt + ct2 where x is in meters and t is in class 11 physics CBSE

Trending doubts
One Metric ton is equal to kg A 10000 B 1000 C 100 class 11 physics CBSE

What do you mean by retardation What is its SI uni class 11 physics CBSE

Draw a diagram of nephron and explain its structur class 11 biology CBSE

10 examples of friction in our daily life

Difference between physical and chemical change class 11 chemistry CBSE

Proton was discovered by A Thomson B Rutherford C Chadwick class 11 chemistry CBSE

